Inside a rancher family's clash with gov't that could have ripple effect right to SCOTUS: ‘Existential threat’
According to Fox News, a multigenerational cattle ranch faces an "existential threat" after the Washington State Department of Ecology fined the owners $267,540 for allegedly damaging regulated wetlands by digging stockwater ponds. The Kings argue the areas are longstanding livestock ponds, not wetlands, and that compliance costs could exceed $3.7 million.
The department ordered restoration of 34 areas, claiming satellite imagery from 1949 shows 6.37 acres of naturally occurring wetlands were damaged. The Kings challenged the fines but were directed to the Pollution Control Hearings Board, which does not provide jury trials. A superior court dismissed their lawsuit, ruling they must complete the administrative process first. An appeals court paused the board proceedings while considering their jury trial claim.
Their attorney says they will petition the U.S. Supreme Court if unsuccessful, arguing the Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial applies against states. A ruling could affect ranchers nationwide. The department says the Kings refused cooperation; the Kings say they have always protected the land they rely on.
Source
Written with the help of AI by Ghostwriter KIERO SWISS from the sources named in the article. About the author and how we write