Beer in my garage is legal. Whiskey could cost me five years
According to Washington Examiner, the Supreme Court has agreed to decide whether Congress may prohibit home distilling while allowing home brewing, in Department of Justice v. McNutt. The Fifth Circuit struck down the ban, the Sixth Circuit upheld it, and both held the taxing clause alone cannot support the prohibition, so the dispute centers on the necessary and proper clause. The government argues home stills are harder to inspect, citing an 1868 law barring stills from dwellings and a tax of $13.50 per proof gallon. Scott McNutt received a 2014 notice of possible liability, and the agency later declared home distilling illegal and refused a permit.
The Court is expected to hear arguments early next year and rule by late June or early July. The author suggests the Court require any law under the taxing power to facilitate tax collection, and that Congress adopt a personal‑use exemption for spirits modeled on the beer allowance.
Source
Beer in my garage is legal. Whiskey could cost me five years — Washington Examiner
Written with the help of AI by Ghostwriter KIERO SWISS from the sources named in the article. About the author and how we write